Our organic clicks are falling because of AI Overviews. What should we do?

First, confirm the cause: in Search Console, look for queries where impressions held steady but click-through rate fell, and check whether an AI Overview now shows for them. Then split the loss by intent. Informational queries lose the most clicks, so measure those by whether the Overview cites you. Rewrite those pages so a direct answer is easy to lift. Move effort toward comparison, pricing and product queries, where buyers still click.
Is the drop really caused by AI Overviews?
Probably partly, and the evidence is now strong enough to plan around.
Pew Research tracked 900 US adults in March 2025. When a Google results page showed an AI summary, people clicked a regular result on 8% of visits, against 15% when it did not. Only 1% of visits clicked a link inside the summary (Pew Research Center).
Ahrefs compared 300,000 keywords and found that an AI Overview now correlates with a 58% lower average click-through rate for the top-ranking page, using December 2025 data. They call it a correlation, and the data is desktop only (Ahrefs).
Seer Interactive's 53-brand dataset shows the 2025 decline did not continue into January and February 2026, though click-through rate stayed below pre-Overview levels (Seer Interactive).
But other causes produce the same curve: a ranking loss, a seasonal dip, a site migration, or a tracking change. Rule them out before you rewrite anything.
How do you confirm it in Search Console?
Google counts clicks from AI Overviews and AI Mode inside the normal Performance report, under the Web search type, so there is no separate AI Overviews filter (Google Search Central). You have to infer it.
Open Performance, compare the last three months with the same three months a year earlier, and turn on clicks, impressions, CTR and position.
Sort queries by lost clicks. Keep the ones where impressions held or grew and average position held, but CTR fell. That pattern means people still see you and choose not to click.
Search the top 20 of those queries yourself, signed out, and note whether an AI Overview appears and whether your page is among its links.
Tag each query by intent: informational ("what is", "how to"), commercial ("best", "vs", "pricing") or navigational (your brand).
Repeat for pages, not just queries, so you know which URLs carry the loss.
If position also fell, you have a ranking problem first, and the AI Overview is a second issue. Tools can do this split for you, including our own visibility agent, DRIS, covered in its own section below.
Which queries lose the most, and which ones still convert?
Informational queries carry most of the loss, because an Overview can answer them in full. Buyers on commercial queries still click, because they want detail an answer box cannot hold: prices, feature limits, contracts and proof.
Seer's figures make the point that being cited matters. On informational queries in 2025, organic CTR averaged 2.07% when the brand was cited in the Overview, 0.94% when it was not, and 3.35% where no Overview showed (Seer Interactive). So there are three states for each query:
No Overview. Classic rules apply. Rank and earn the click.
Overview, you are not cited. The worst case. You lose the click and the mention.
Overview, you are cited. You lose some clicks but keep visibility and a share of the traffic.
Your job on informational queries is to move pages from the second state to the third.
How do you get cited inside an AI Overview?
Google says there are no extra technical requirements: a page must be indexed and eligible for a snippet, and normal SEO fundamentals apply. You do not need special files or new schema types (Google Search Central). What changes is how lifting-friendly the page is.
Answer first. Put a two to three sentence answer directly under each question heading. Hedging openers lose to pages that answer.
Name things. Use specific products, numbers and sources. Vague claims give an engine nothing to quote.
One question per section. Short, self-contained sections are easier to extract than long essays.
Keep structured data consistent with the visible text. Google states this as a fundamental, not a ranking trick.
Check snippet controls. A
nosnippetor tightmax-snippetsetting can keep a page out of the Overview. Remove them where you want to be quoted.Refresh. Citations fade. Profound found the median page loses half its citation share within 11 days of its peak, so put key pages on a refresh schedule and re-check them after each update (Profound).
What should change in your content plan?
Rebalance, do not abandon.
Informational pages: keep the best, rewrite them answer-first, and measure them by Overview citation and assisted conversions, not clicks alone.
Commercial pages: build comparison, alternatives, pricing and use-case pages that answer what a buyer asks just before a shortlist. These hold clicks better and convert better.
Product proof: documentation, implementation guides and case pages. Engines answer these poorly, and buyers who reach them are close to deciding.
Other engines: your buyers also ask ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini, which cite different sources. Track those too, or you will optimize for one surface and miss the rest.
How should you report this to leadership?
Lead with the structural change, then show what you control.
Clicks and CTR by intent group, this quarter against last year.
The share of your top informational queries where an Overview appears, and the share where you are cited.
AI referrals from Google Analytics 4: sessions from chatgpt.com, perplexity.ai and similar sources.
Pipeline from commercial pages, which should hold even as total clicks fall.
For a full template, see how to report AEO results to executives and how to set AEO goals with your CFO.
Which mistakes make the drop worse?
Blocking crawlers in a panic. Blocking Googlebot or adding
noindexremoves you from normal results as well as the Overview. Blocking OAI-SearchBot keeps you out of ChatGPT search answers, by OpenAI's own account (OpenAI).Publishing more of the same. Ten new "what is" posts add more pages to the losing state. Rewrite the pages that already rank first.
Reporting total clicks only. A blended number hides that commercial queries may be fine. Leadership then cuts the budget that still works.
Changing everything at once. If you rewrite 40 pages in a week, you cannot tell which change moved the citation. Ship in small batches and log dates.
Which tools can measure this for you?
Search Console alone cannot tell you whether you were cited. A tracker fills that gap.
Ahrefs Brand Radar tracks AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Copilot and Gemini; custom prompts start at $50 a month (Ahrefs, checked 24 October 2026).
Semrush sells an AI Visibility Toolkit add-on at $99 a month with 25 tracked prompts (Semrush, checked 24 October 2026).
Peec AI tracks AI Mode and AI Overviews among its models, from $95 a month (Peec AI, checked 24 October 2026).
Profound and AthenaHQ also cover Google's AI surfaces; Profound's paid plans are quoted by sales, and AthenaHQ starts free.
Where does Nagent's DRIS fit?
We make Nagent, and its visibility agent DRIS is built for this exact situation: classic search and answer engines in one view, with fixes that wait for a person.
DRIS reads your Search Console daily after a first 90-day pull, and Google Analytics 4, where visits from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot and Claude show as their own sources.
Coverage gaps lists pages ranking on page two and pages with below-par click-through, from your own Search Console.
For each tracked page, Share of answers by channel shows how often each chatbot and Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode cited you.
You declare the number you are trying to move, such as organic clicks or AI answer presence, with a date, and the Queue ranks fixes by how much each contributes. Pages with impressions but too few clicks rise.
Approved titles, descriptions, headings and structured data reach your site through a one-time site connection. FAQ and direct-answer fixes arrive as ready-to-paste snippets. Nothing on a live page changes without a person.
What it does not do: it cannot see which landing page an AI visit arrived on, it does not publish directly to WordPress or Shopify, and backlink analysis is coming soon. Work is metered in credits; an AEO page audit is about 10. See DRIS and pricing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are my clicks falling when my rankings have not changed?
An AI Overview answers the query above your result, so people see your page but do not need to click. Rising or flat impressions with flat position and lower CTR is the usual sign.
Does being cited in an AI Overview still bring traffic?
Some. Seer found informational queries averaged 2.07% CTR when the brand was cited against 0.94% when it was not. Fewer clicks than a page with no Overview, but more than twice the uncited rate.
What is answer engine optimization and how is it different from SEO?
SEO aims to rank a page and win the click. Answer engine optimization aims to have AI answers name and cite you. The fundamentals overlap, but AEO adds answer-first writing, prompt tracking and measuring citations rather than positions.
Can I opt out of AI Overviews?
Only by limiting snippets with nosnippet, data-nosnippet or max-snippet, or by removing the page from Search with noindex. Both reduce your visibility in normal results too, so most teams do not.
Want a second pair of eyes on your Search Console data? Book a Nagent demo.