Skip to content
NagentNagent
Log inSign upHire your AI Growth Team
NagentNagent
Log inSign up

How to review a video edit against the creative brief

9 Minutes read
Published:
Review a video edit in passes, each tied to one part of the brief: message, claims, mandatories, brand, format and technical quality. Here is the checklist, how to write feedback an editor can act on, and who should sign off.
PB
Pratap BeheraNov 10, 2026·9 min read
How to review a video edit against the creative brief

To review a video edit against the creative brief, put the brief, script and specs beside the player and watch the cut several times, each time checking one thing: the message, every claim and on-screen word, the mandatory elements, the brand, the format for each placement and the technical quality. Note each issue with a timestamp and the line of the brief it breaks, separate brief misses from taste, and send one consolidated list to the editor with a named approver.

Below: what to have open before you press play, the order of the passes, how to check claims and placements, how to write feedback an editor can act on, how AI video tools handle review today and what a weak review costs. Nagent's video teammate Alpha runs an automated proof check before a person reviews a cut, and it has its own section near the end.

What should you have open before you press play?

A review is only as good as the reference it is checked against. Open these side by side:

  • The brief: objective, audience, the single message, the call to action and any mandatory lines.

  • The approved script or storyboard: every line of voice-over and every super, in order, with timings.

  • The claims sheet: each number, comparison or testimonial on screen, with its source.

  • The brand guide: logo use, colours, type, tone and end card rules.

  • The placement specs: ratio, length and safe zones for every version you will run.

  • The previous round's notes, so you can confirm each one was fixed.

If any of these is missing, write it down first. "Make it pop" is not a brief, and an edit cannot fail a test nobody wrote.

In what order should you review the edit?

Watch the whole cut once as a viewer before you judge anything, then make focused passes. Each pass answers one question.

  1. Viewer pass, sound on, then sound off. Did you get the message in the first three seconds? Many feeds autoplay without sound, so the sound-off watch tells you whether the supers carry it alone.

  2. Message pass. Does the cut say the one thing the brief asked for, to the audience it named? Is the call to action the one in the brief, worded the same way?

  3. Claims pass. Read every word on screen and listen to every spoken line against the script and the claims sheet.

  4. Mandatories pass. Logo, legal lines, offer terms, price, disclosure of AI-generated presenters, and anything the brief marked "must".

  5. Brand pass. Colours, type, logo placement and the end card against the brand guide. Tone of voice against the brief.

  6. Format pass, per placement. Ratio, length, safe zones and captions for every version.

  7. Technical pass. Audio levels, captions in sync, no black or frozen frames, no soft or stretched footage, correct resolution.

Splitting the passes stops the common failure where a reviewer gets absorbed in music choice and misses a wrong price.

How do you check claims and on-screen words?

This is the pass with the most risk and the one most often skipped.

  • Read every super aloud and match it word for word to the approved script. Editors retype supers, and AI tools sometimes generate text inside the footage.

  • Circle every number, price and percentage, then find each on the claims sheet. A figure with no source comes out, whoever added it.

  • Check product shots against the real pack. Label, colour, cap and logo must match the product people will receive.

  • Check testimonials and presenters. If a presenter is AI-generated, the disclosure must be on screen where the brief requires it. In the US, the FTC rule on reviews and testimonials prohibits creating a testimonial that misrepresents that the testimonialist exists or used the product (16 CFR 465.2).

  • Check pronunciation of your brand and product names in voice-overs, especially in translated versions.

How do you check each placement?

A cut that works in 16:9 can fail in 9:16. Review every version on a phone-sized player, not only the master.

  • Safe zones. Meta asks advertisers to keep at least 14% of the top, 35% of the bottom and 6% of each side of a Reels ad free of copy and logos (Meta ads guide). Pause on each super and check it clears those margins.

  • Length. Confirm each version's running time against the brief, not just the master's.

  • Crop damage. In resized versions, check that faces, hands and the product label were not cut off.

  • End card. The logo and call to action must be readable in each ratio, not shrunk from the widescreen version.

How do you write feedback an editor can act on?

Good feedback is specific, located and tied to the brief. Use this format for every note:

  • Timestamp: 00:07 to 00:09.

  • What is wrong: "Super reads '40% faster'."

  • Why, with the brief reference: "Claims sheet has no source for 40%; brief section 4."

  • What you want instead: "Use the approved line 'Set up in one afternoon'."

  • Priority: must fix (breaks the brief or a rule) or suggestion (taste).

Then follow three rules:

  1. One consolidated list per round. Collect every reviewer's notes, resolve conflicts between them, and send one list. Contradictory notes from three people are the main cause of extra rounds.

  2. Separate brief misses from preference. A wrong call to action is a must fix. "I prefer a warmer track" is a suggestion unless the brief specified the mood.

  3. Do not reopen approved decisions. If the storyboard was approved, a note that changes the concept at edit stage is a new brief, and should be treated and budgeted as one.

How do AI video tools handle review today?

Most tools let you review the plan before rendering, and some add comments or proofreading after. As checked on 24 October 2026:

  • HeyGen. Video Agent shows the script split into scenes for editing before you generate a draft, and you can then ask for changes in chat, after which it "builds a new version" (HeyGen). Its help page does not say whether a revision re-renders every scene or what it costs. For translations, HeyGen's Proofreader lets you edit the translated script before the final video, and you can invite a native-speaker proofreader to a shared folder (HeyGen).

  • Creatify. Its Workspace adds team roles and commenting for feedback on projects (Creatify). The article describes no formal approval or sign-off step.

  • Arcads. Its guidance on consistency is to settle the voice and look before generating, to reduce later fixes (Arcads).

What none of these describe is a check of the finished cut against the brief itself: its claims, its mandatories and its placements. That pass is still a person's job, with the checklist above.

Who should sign off, and when?

  • The brief owner approves the storyboard and the final cut. They know what the ad is for.

  • A second reader checks claims and legal lines when the ad makes comparisons, prices or health, finance or safety claims.

  • The brand owner checks the first ad of a new campaign, then delegates.

  • Approve the plan, not just the result. Most expensive changes come from concept notes made at edit stage. Signing off a storyboard first keeps the edit review about execution.

Name the approver in the brief. "The team will review" means nobody will.

What does a weak review cost?

  • Rejected or paused ads when a platform flags text, claims or disclosures.

  • Legal and trust risk from an unsourced number or an undisclosed AI presenter.

  • Extra edit rounds, each of which costs editor time or render credits.

  • Wasted media on a cut whose offer sits under the call-to-action button.

  • Lost learning when an ad that ran was not the ad the brief described, so its results teach you nothing. For closing that loop, see turning ad performance data into the next creative brief.

Where does Nagent fit?

We make Nagent, so read this as a vendor's own description. Nagent is multiplayer AI for growth: people and AI agents in one shared context, delivering the number. Its video teammate, Alpha, on CREA's Content team, builds two review points into every video job.

  • Before rendering. A person approves the storyboard and its credit quote. The words on screen come from copy a person supplies or from a HOOK brief (HOOK is in Beta).

  • After the cut, PROOF. Alpha's proof step checks each rendition and writes one report: the file spec, loudness, black or frozen frames, the product against its image, the disclosure layer and Content Credentials. It also reads the words on screen and names any line or figure nobody gave, checks that nothing sits in the part of the frame the platform covers, that the spoken words match the storyboard and that a presenter's lips move with them.

  • A person still decides. A report that blocks fails the job; any other waits for a person to read it before the cut is released. PROOF can misread, so some checks ask for a fix rather than hold the cut back. Read the words on the cut yourself.

  • What it does not do. PROOF does not judge whether the ad is persuasive or on strategy, and Alpha does not publish or touch an ad account.

See how this works on product ad videos, or start from the Alpha page.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many review rounds should a video edit get?

Plan for two: one round of consolidated notes on the first cut and a check of the fixes on the second. If a third round is needed, it usually means the storyboard was not approved or the notes conflicted.

What is the difference between a brief miss and a creative preference?

A brief miss breaks something the brief or a rule states: the wrong message, call to action, claim, mandatory line or spec. A preference is a matter of taste the brief left open. Fix the first every time; discuss the second.

Why do people watch my video ads but not click?

Often the edit holds attention but the offer or call to action is weak, late or hidden. Check that the call to action matches the brief, appears before the end card and sits outside the platform's covered areas.

Should the person who wrote the brief review the edit?

Yes, for the message and the call to action. Add a second reader for claims and legal lines, because the brief's author is the person most likely to read what they meant rather than what is on screen.

Want every cut checked before a person signs it off? Book a Nagent demo.

Continue learning

Related agents

Agents that match this read.

Browse all 200+ agents
Select Category
Marketing

How to Write a Creative Brief for AI with HOOK

How to write a creative brief an AI can work from: fill in the brand pack first, file a request with the right detail, know what each of HOOK's sub-agents does, and read the bets and kill conditions that come back.

Marketing AI

Turn Ad Performance Data Into the Next Creative Brief

The most useful output of any campaign is a single sentence for the next brief. Ad performance data tells you which angle worked, for which buyer, and with what proof. Here is how to close the loop.

Creative

Do AI video generator credits roll over?

Some do and some do not. HeyGen, Captions and Creatify carry unused credits for a limited time, Arcads rolls them over on Pro and above, Runway only on Max, and Synthesia resets monthly allowances. Here is each policy, checked on 24 October 2026.

Creative

What does UGC mean in video ads?

UGC stands for user-generated content. In video ads it usually means creator-style ads that look like a real person's post, whether made by customers, paid creators or AI presenters. Here is what each type is, the common formats, and the rights and disclosure rules.

Creative

How much does a video ad cost to produce?

A video ad can cost a few dollars in AI tool credits, a few hundred dollars from a UGC creator, or $2,000 to $50,000 and more from a production company. Here are the ranges by route, what drives them, the hidden costs and a worked budget.

Creative

Why do AI videos look like slow motion?

AI video looks slow when one action is stretched across a whole clip, when style words like cinematic invite floaty motion, when a frame rate is conformed wrongly, or when the voice-over drags. Here are the causes, the fix for each and a check before an ad ships.